
Columnist Ruchika Malhotra, far right, at Third Place Books in Seattle with, from right, Dr. Laura Marie Rivera, Stefanie O'Connell and Kathy Ridgewell Williams. Photo courtesy Dr. Laura Marie Rivera
If you read my first column, you’ll know I’ve been chewing over the idea of “women’s ambition” for a while. Many women I’m meeting are rethinking what ambition means to them (and redefining it) at a time when record numbers of women –– particularly Black women –– are leaving the corporate workplace, affordable childcare remains a huge issue, more of us are living in the sandwich generation of also caretaking our parents/older relatives…and that’s just the surface.
Then there’s having to navigate an ambition penalty when women do express ambition in the same way men do. That’s the premise of journalist and author Stefanie O’Connell’s new book, The Ambition Penalty. Stefanie was recently in Seattle and invited me to moderate her book talk at Third Place Books.
It’s an excellent, data-driven read for all of us who came up in the “We are girl bosses and women can do everything, bring home the bacon and cook it too” era…and a cautionary tale of what happens when we go from Girl Boss to Tradwife, two social media tropes that are remarkably similar in how they’re steeped in shaming women for not doing enough and both uphold patriarchal expectations.
Stefanie’s book begins with a story of interviewing a woman who negotiated her salary (like “Lean In” told us to do) and found that her job offer was rescinded.
We’re enraged to read stories like this. But let’s also be honest: We all feel that unfamiliar je ne sais quoi when a woman comes off as too ambitious — she’s pushy, aggressive, ungrateful, a bit of a bitch. I’m certainly not immune from these thoughts despite covering this topic for nearly two decades. Women face a likeability trap that men don’t — the impossible double standards of trying to be respected and liked at work. Most fall on either side of the spectrum; They’re liked but not respected or respected and not liked.
It would perhaps be acceptable if these were just about interpersonal dynamics, but it impacts decisions on who gets hired, promoted, advanced, paid more, given the high-visibility projects. The ambition penalty for being too ambitious has serious consequences on a woman’s career.
It doesn't stop there. Stefanie cites Australian data that found a 35% increase in domestic violence when women outearned their male partners. This made me sit up straighter, because coming from a lineage where married women were not permitted to earn money, it reminded me that simply making more money isn’t the clearest way to leave a bad relationship.
When I have these conversations, and read these books, it can be demoralizing to know that progress seems impossible. Are we still facing these issues in 2026? Where do we go from here?
Stefanie’s advice was hopeful; when we talk about gender bias, we realize it’s not an individual issue that requires us to lean in or negotiate harder or change ourselves to fit in. We stop gaslighting ourselves (those from the Girl Boss era know what I’m talking about) to believe systemic issues like pay inequality or sexist remarks can be “leaned in” away.
Also important: generously passing on information to other women, like how much they can really negotiate in that job offer (no matter what’s advertised). What’s it like to really work at that organization. Who is a champion and who isn’t?
That knowledge at scale can be a powerful antidote to the systems that punish women. I’d add: try not to judge other women for their ambition — or what we consider, a lack of it. If you overhear someone say: “Ruchika’s a bit too aggressive,” maybe counteract with: “Really? I don’t see her that way. Would we say the same words about a man behaving that way?”
Kathy Ridgewell-Williams, a pioneering soccer player on the very first U.S. Women's National Team in 1985, was in the audience the night of the book talk. She’s been trying to change the game for women since well before I or Stefanie were born and reminded us that our rights are hard-earned and need continued vigilance.
What she said with me stayed on in my mind: She mentioned how her entry into soccer was because of Title IX legislation and the work of women and advocates who came before her. “We took it for granted and just played soccer. It wasn’t about what we were doing to keep those rights in place. But now I see we’ve got to keep working on defending and creating more rights for the women coming after us.”
As someone who wrote a book about ending women’s competition at work and in life, I can only say, “hell yeah!”
— Column by Ruchika T. Malhotra, [email protected]

